Cards are sorted from greatest mean to least mean.
View data for the pre-expansion voting here.
95.65: Chromatic Duel
95.28: Fatal Spellbomb
94.32: Valse, Magical Marksman
93.49: Sky Fortress
92.86: Ceryneian Darkhind
92.78: Ceryneian Hind
90.83: La Diablotine Miriam
89.29: Dragoncleaver Roy
88.21: Sky Commander Celia
87.16: Miriam, Synthetic Being
87.16: Moriae Encomium
86.64: Celia, Despair's Messenger
86.50: Moon and Sun
85.83: L'Ange Miriam
85.63: Orchis, Vengeful Puppet
85.00: Amaterasu
84.76: Eternal Potion
84.38: Dragonlife Blade
83.65: Marionette//Tre
83.62: Queen Hemera the White
83.33: Queen Magnus the Black
82.76: Celia, Hope's Strategist
82.26: Holy King Lion
82.14: Marionette//Due
81.82: White Diamond
81.55: Dragonstrife Blade
80.08: Runie, Destiny's Bard
79.81: Vania, Nightshade Vampire
79.50: Orchis, Puppet Girl
79.49: Jeweled Priestess
79.49: Blood Queen Vania
79.27: Tsukuyomi
78.33: Victoria
78.13: Prophecy of Boons
78.05: Kind Queen Vania
77.83: Ceridwen, Eternity Hunter
76.92: Ceryneian Lighthind
76.47: Summon Bloodkin
76.09: Iniquitous Lindworm
75.94: Holy Purebomb
75.94: Wrath of Nature
75.64: Oldblood King
75.46: Snowman King
75.00: Orchis, Resolute Puppet
74.42: Demon's Dress
74.04: Holy Bear Knight
73.86: Zwei, Murderous Puppet
73.65: White Breath
73.21: Gift for Bloodkin
72.66: Prime Artifact
72.56: Waters of the Orca
72.12: Prophecy of Doom
72.06: Buller, Dark Maiden
70.27: Buller, Blood Maiden
70.27: Black Breath
69.87: Instant Potion
69.70: Black Diamond
69.64: Wild Snowman
69.14: Yggdrasil
68.87: Blessings of Creation
68.75: Galua of Two Breaths
68.18: Fashionista Nelcha
67.86: Snow Knight
67.50: Somniferous Whitewyrm
66.96: Marionette//Uno
66.96: Lloyd the Android
66.67: Red Talonstrike
66.22: Paradise Vanguard
66.22: Holy Lion Crystal
65.54: Temple of the Holy Lion
65.24: Force of the Dragonewt
64.67: Paula, Passionate Warmth
64.63: Darkfeast Bat
64.39: Nightmare Devil
64.06: Flower of Fairies
63.97: Buller, Saintly Maiden
63.75: Everdark Stryx
63.27: Lindworm
62.98: Paula, Icy Warmth
62.77: Absolute Zeroblade
62.50: Knower of History
61.29: Holy Plate Lion
60.71: Peaceweaver
60.34: Blade of Dark
59.66: Paula, Gentle Warmth
59.46: Mysterian Blackwyrm
59.13: Innocent Princess Prim
57.93: Witch of Foresight
57.14: Devil of the Gaps
56.90: Unbodied Witch
56.40: Mysterian Wyrmist
55.81: Summoning Drills
55.26: White Vanara
54.76: Angel's Dress
54.55: Virtuous Lindworm
54.27: Beastfaced Mage
54.17: Staff of Whirlwinds
53.68: Silverchain Disciple
53.03: Junk
52.14: Orator of the Bones
51.60: Forest Whispers
51.50: Jerva of Draconic Mail
50.81: Holy Shield Lion
49.11: Blade of Light
49.11: Hexed Fowl of Ebon
48.57: Tenko's Shrine
48.44: Spellplate Cavalier
48.44: Bone Cavalier
48.03: Fickle Resurrector
47.44: Godsworn Alexiel
46.53: Mysterian Whitewyrm
46.43: Big Soul Hunter
46.35: Grasshopper Conductor
45.41: Nonja, Silent Maid
44.85: Regenerate Spirit
44.64: Swiftgait Okami
44.44: Holy Fowl of Ivory
44.29: Divine Retribution
44.15: Hinterland Ghoul
42.42: Opposing Statues
41.18: Fount of Angels
37.50: Suttungr
37.07: Dirk, Steelarm Battler
36.29: Crystal Cannon
35.81: Tart Man
35.16: Cruel Puppetmaster
34.38: Elusa, Magic Wunderkind
34.17: Rocket Knuckles
33.59: Poltergeist
33.33: Dragon's Handspur
32.89: That Which Erases
31.62: Delirious Demon
31.45: Valkyrie of Chaos
31.25: Valkyrie of Order
31.25: Heroic Dragonslayer
29.31: Hell Lord Skeleton
29.26: Elf General
27.59: Giant Skull
26.53: Owl Man
25.00: Deathscythe Nun
24.34: Mighty Arm Skeleton
24.26: Mischievous Spirit
23.33: Axe Princess
22.66: Lycaon
21.71: Dragonclad Blademaster
21.62: Drakewing Assassin
19.15: Master Samurai
19.02: Frontline Ramparts
18.92: Twilight Dragoon Coda
18.48: Savage Swordsman
17.86: Marduk
17.65: Death the Nyctophile
17.05: Servant of the Spellgrove
13.89: Calamity's Archdemon
11.88: Moonshade Mage