Cards are sorted from greatest mean to least mean.
View data for the pre-expansion voting here.
97.44: Demonlord Eachtar
96.79: Grimnir, War Cyclone
96.65: Prince Catacomb
95.18: Sibyl of the Waterwyrm
95.06: Luminous Mage
93.45: Crystalia Aerin
91.12: Wind Reader Zell
90.67: Rahab
89.94: Ouroboros
88.36: Belphegor
86.89: Lightning Blast
85.96: Israfil
85.94: Orthrus
83.56: Little Soulsquasher
83.55: Zombie Party
81.43: Heavenly Aegis
78.93: Dark Airjammer
78.72: Dragoon Scyther
77.54: Spiderweb Imp
77.30: Vagabond Frog
76.87: Baphomet
75.83: Jungle Warden
74.66: Immortal Thane
74.64: Freshman Lou
73.51: Judge of Retribution
71.60: Elf Queen
68.01: Blood Moon
67.19: Goblin Princess
65.77: Halo Golem
65.58: Maelstrom Serpent
65.36: Roland the Incorruptible
64.39: Arriet, Soothing Harpist
64.33: Beetle Warrior
64.02: Hulking Giant
62.04: Gawain of the Round Table
61.59: Soul Dominator
60.23: Dark Jeanne
60.07: Mutagenic Bolt
59.47: Mask of the Black Death
57.97: Magic Girl Melvie
57.14: Gravekeeper Sonia
56.25: Captain Lecia
54.03: Test of Strength
53.85: Enchanted Library
53.04: Vist, Elf Butler
52.90: Zeus
51.69: Naval Guard Simone
51.19: Tarnished Grail
51.14: Mage of Nightfall
50.39: Phoenix Rider Aina
50.36: Death's Ledger
49.23: Candelabra of Prayers
49.18: Earthshock Ogre
48.61: Sukuna, Brave and Small
48.44: Octobishop
46.03: Holy Bowman Kel
45.77: Galretto, Devil of Love
45.45: Captain Walfrid
45.38: Enchanted Sword
45.08: Dragon's Nest
45.08: Frozen Mammoth
44.23: Magic Illusionist
42.91: Wrath Drake
42.08: Wandering Bard Elta
41.94: Mist Shaman
41.79: Minthe of the Underworld
41.67: Support Cannon
41.43: Man-Eating Mangrove
40.00: Elder Mage of Dragonlore
39.39: Dolorblade Warrior
39.06: Iron Maiden
38.71: Zoe, Queen of Goldenia
37.08: Impartial Strix
36.74: Deadmoon Disciple
35.82: Venomous Pucewyrm
35.67: Cybele
35.00: Owlcat
34.91: Axe Fighter
34.43: Pure Healer
33.71: Aqua Nereid
32.03: Chimera
30.92: Shrouded Assassin
30.00: Ivy Spellbomb
29.23: Hippocampus
29.01: Jolly Rogers
27.96: Luminous Standard
27.08: Dryad
27.02: Deepwood Anomaly
26.61: Wordwielder Ginger
26.23: Calydonian Boar
25.77: Goblin Zombie
25.68: Tristan of the Round Table
24.18: Frogbat
23.48: Stolen Life
23.48: Grave Desecration
19.92: Assault Werewolf
19.62: Ebon Reaper
19.59: Fairy Cage
19.23: Dazzling Healer
18.75: Wise Merman
14.66: Mighty Dwarf
13.71: Vlad
10.71: Dragonslayer's Price
7.89: Spring Cleaning